Safety Sound seen from a Bering Air flight on June 24, 2024. Ben Townsend/KNOM

Federal judge rules Army Corps unlawfully permitted IPOP gold dredging project near Nome

A federal judge has ruled that the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers broke the law when it approved a permit for a large gold dredging project in the Bonanza Channel of Safety Sound, about 25 miles east of Nome. Five Bering Strait tribes sued to stop the project.

In a decision filed Nov. 2, U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason found that the Corps' Pacific Ocean Division failed to explain why it overruled its own Alaska District and other federal agencies, which had concluded the project posed serious environmental risks. The judge called the permit's issuance "arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law."

The permit, granted to IPOP LLC in 2024, has not been thrown out yet. Gleason ordered both sides to file briefs on what should happen to it.

The plaintiffs are the Village of Solomon, the Native Village of Council, King Island Native Community, Chinik Eskimo Community and the Native Village of White Mountain. The nonprofit law firm Earthjustice represents them.

Deilah Johnson is the Village of Solomon's tribal resources director and an elected member of its council. She said reading the decision was emotional after years of fighting the project.

"It's a relief, but it's also exhausting," Johnson said.

A reversal on appeal

According to its permit application, IPOP plans to use a cutter-head suction dredge to mine placer gold from the Bonanza Channel and an adjacent tidal lagoon. Plans approved by the Corps in March 2024 sought to dredge 4.5 million cubic yards of material over five years, with permanent disposal on 159.4 acres, according to the ruling.

The Corps' Alaska District, a subset of the Corps’ Pacific Ocean Division initially denied IPOP's Clean Water Act permit in September 2022. IPOP appealed to the Hawaii-based Pacific Ocean Division, which vacated the denial and later issued the permit without preparing a full environmental impact statement.

"The Pacific [Ocean] Division reversed that denial basically without saying anything about the concerns that had been raised by all the expert agencies and its own district," said Erin Colón, a senior attorney in Earthjustice's Alaska office and the lead attorney on the case.

Judge Gleason agreed, saying that she found the Pacific Ocean Division relied on IPOP's own studies of seafloor life and underwater vegetation, which the Alaska District had found flawed, without explaining why it disagreed. Where the Alaska District found major impacts on birds, the division found minor or temporary ones, again without explanation.

"The Pacific Division failed to explain why it disagreed with the District's analysis and other agencies' findings, rendering its decision to issue the Permit arbitrary and capricious," Gleason wrote in her decision. 

The judge did not decide whether the project requires a full environmental impact statement.

What the tribes say is at stake

The Bonanza Channel about 25 miles east of Nome, where IPOP, LLC has attempted to earn permits to dredge for gold. Courtesy Tyler Bell/SalmonState.

Colón said IPOP plans to dredge the bottom of the estuary down to 30 feet. By Earthjustice's calculation, the material removed would equal about 2 1⁄2 Great Pyramids of Giza. She said compacted sediment bulks up once it is dredged, so extra material would have to be dumped in special aquatic sites, and that nothing in the record shows the small organisms on the estuary floor would recover quickly.

"All of that has a chain effect on the food chain, on up to birds, wildlife, and ultimately humans," Colón said. "No mine should be able to plunder lands and waters that have fed Alaska Native people for thousands of years without a very careful public process and informed consent from the tribes."

Johnson said the estuary feeds the entire Safety Sound watershed near where the village of Solomon initially settled. Birders from around the world travel to Safety Sound each year to see its waterfowl. It’s also a known habitat for several species of fish including salmon. 

The Village of Solomon, known in Iñupiaq as Aŋuutaq, is a displaced community. Families left after the Bureau of Indian Affairs closed the village school, and no one has been counted as living there since the early 2000s. The tribal office is in Nome.

"As a displaced community, the time that we feel wholesome and united and connected is when we're out in our land," Johnson said. "It's where we come from, and it's a part of who we are."

In their court filings, the tribes argued that the Corps relied on IPOP's information even as the company dismissed environmental concerns. According to the tribes' reply brief, IPOP called the idea that salmon use the site "absurd" and objected to a 2022 fish study by the Corps and the Village of Solomon. That study found live coho, chum and pink salmon in and near the project site. IPOP then argued that pink salmon are invasive, the brief says.

Johnson has worked for the tribe since 2012. She said she has worked for years on the IPOP fight, which has gone on for almost a decade. 

She said the Alaska District's denial came just days before the remnants of Typhoon Merbok struck the region in September 2022, so there was no time to celebrate. The tribe later learned from a reporter, not from the Corps, that the denial had been vacated and sent up to the Pacific Ocean Division.

"No one notified us that an appeal was even occurring," Johnson said.

State permit denied, IPOP appeal pending in court

IPOP also needs a state permit to mine. The Alaska Department of Natural Resources denied IPOP's permit application twice, and in March the commissioner's office upheld the second denial. IPOP's appeal of the state's decision is pending in court.

The state's main concern was over IPOP’s claim site exploration. All of IPOP's exploration data came from 2019, when 13 drill holes and a 323-pound sample produced 7 grams of gold – about a quarter of an ounce. 

According to the Department of Natural Resources' March decision, the samples were combined into one batch before testing, so there is no way to tell which drill hole, claim or depth the gold came from. State geologists concluded the results can't support even an inferred gold resource.

DNR said IPOP's proposal would make it "the largest placer operation in Alaska today," at up to 900,000 cubic yards a year, and found that dredging on that scale without better data would cause "unnecessary and undue degradation" of state land and water. The decision said "a prudent operator would have conducted sufficient exploration of its claim sites prior to requesting a production permit."

The decision also quoted a 2017 promotional video for investors from Rivers of Gold, which IPOP calls its parent company. In it, Edwin "Ed" Epstein Jr., who then ran Rivers of Gold and was IPOP's sole owner, describes the company's approach: "We don't try to think where the high pay grade area is, we suck it all out."

DNR received 53 comments on the application, 51 of them from the public, and none of the public comments supported the project, according to the DNR decision. The state said IPOP could reapply once it has more exploration data.

What comes next

Both sides will now file briefs on the remedy. Colón said the court could vacate the permit, as the tribes have asked, modify it, or leave it on the books while the court keeps jurisdiction. The tribes argue that because the state has already denied IPOP's mining permit, throwing out the federal permit wouldn't disrupt anything.

KNOM asked the Corps' Pacific Ocean Division and its Alaska District, and IPOP, for comment on the ruling on Nov. 12.

The Pacific Ocean Division's public affairs office said in an email Nov. 13 that because the case is still being litigated it could not provide a comment. It did not answer questions about why the division reversed the Alaska District's denial, why the division issued the permit without a full environmental impact statement, or what remedy the division will seek.

John Budnik, a public affairs specialist for the Corps' Alaska District, said the district must defer to the Pacific Ocean Division "as this litigative matter was with them."

James Buchal, an attorney for IPOP, did not respond to an emailed request for comment sent Nov. 12.

Johnson said she expects IPOP to keep pushing, through more appeals or a new application. 

The tribe plans to stay ready.

"I don't have millions and billions of dollars, but I don't think that's necessary either," she said. "That's not how you can win."

Did you enjoy this News story?

Consider supporting our work by becoming a one-time or recurring donor.

Scroll to Top